. All times are London time.

Home US 
Asia | Europe | UK 
Markets data & tools
Comment & analysis
Technology zone
Your money
Arts & Weekend
Jobs & education
In today's FT
Site services
FT Reports
Creative Business
World reports
Business reports

News in depth
   Rebuilding Iraq
 WMD guide
 Science briefing

   Martin Wolf
 Lucy Kellaway
 Quentin Peel
 Amity Shlaes
 Gerard Baker

   Iraq's WMD: Was war justified?
 EU referendum
 UK house prices
 China's economic growth

Partner sites
 CBS MarketWatch
 Les Echos
 FT Deutschland
 The New York Times
 Investors Chronicle

Home US  Print article | Email
Nato urged to challenge European defence plan
By Judy Dempsey in Brussels
Published: October 16 2003 18:20 | Last Updated: October 16 2003 18:20

The US has called an emergency Nato meeting to challenge the creation of a stronger security and defence policy for the European Union.

The call by Nicholas Burns, US ambassador to Nato, reflects growing unease among Pentagon officials over the way Britain wants to work more closely with its EU allies in building credible defence structures and better military capabilities. But it also highlights tensions in the transatlantic alliance, with the US seeing any future EU defence policy as a potential competitor to Nato.

The US move came as EU leaders met last night to discuss how to make European defence more effective in any new constitutional treaty. The draft treaty is being negotiated in the intergovernment conference that includes the 15 current member and 10 candidate states that join next year.

British, French and German officials on Thursday said it was too early to make any decisions over defence issues. "This is only the beginning. We need a more coherent defence policy that will complement Nato," said one British official.

Nevertheless, the Pentagon and the White House are particularly concerned over how Tony Blair, UK prime minister, wants to co-operate over defence with Germany and France, which opposed the US-led attack on Iraq.

"Somehow the US believes that because Britain is considered its staunchest ally, it cannot work with its EU allies," said one European ambassador. "This is ridiculous. If Blair is involved in Europe it means the transatlantic relationship is protected," he added.

Last month, Mr Blair held a summit in Berlin with French President Jacques Chirac and Gerhard Schröder of Germany. They agreed on "structured co-operation" in which a group of countries would take the lead in improving Europe's military capabilities.

France and Germany quietly dropped the idea of creating an independent military headquarters in Tervuren, near Brussels, something the US and Britain believed was a direct challenge to Nato. However, Mr Blair conceded that the EU did need operation planning headquarters if it was to carry out missions independent of Nato.

Mr Burns, a former US ambassador to Greece and State Department spokesman, lambasted such plans at Wednesday's regular meeting of Nato ambassadors. He said EU defence plans represented "one of the greatest dangers to the transatlantic relationship". He insisted Nato should know what kind of defence policies would be contained in the new treaty.

Benoit D'Aboville, French ambassador to Nato, told Mr Burns Nato had no business knowing about internal matters of the EU until they were agreed by its members.

An EU diplomat said the US believed France was setting a hidden agenda. "It believes Paris will use the trio to gradually strengthen the EU's military capabilities and eventually move away from Nato."

British officials, who on Thursday played down the US criticisms, said a Europe with better military capabilities and with Britain involved would lead to greater burden-sharing, especially in the Balkans.

email this EMAIL THIS print this PRINT THIS most popular MOST POPULAR  
Related stories
Philip Stephens: Bending towards Europe on defence  Oct 16 2003 19:58 Requires subscription
Japan to give $1.5bn for rebuilding Iraq  Oct 15 2003 21:20
BA attacked for buying further Heathrow slots  Oct 15 2003 20:14
Lex: Winter Power  Oct 14 2003 20:27 Requires subscription
Lex live: Winter power  Oct 14 2003 16:01 Requires subscription
BA finds further slots for growth at Heathrow  Oct 14 2003 05:00
GE reveals Amersham deal as earnings dip  Oct 13 2003 19:55 Requires subscription
Utilities pull the plug on Australia  Oct 13 2003 19:14 Requires subscription
Hermes adds to pensions team  Oct 13 2003 05:00 Requires subscription
Mogul's son 'best for' BSkyB  Oct 13 2003 05:00 Requires subscription
Requires subscription = requires subscription to FT.com
Search & quotes

  • Power searchRequires subscription
  • My portfolio

  • Editor's choice
      Brussels briefing

    US dismay over Blair's stance on EU defence

    Nato launches rapid reaction force

    Diplomatic notebook: Nato's challenge Requires subscription

    Europe's leaders at odds with ministers on defence

    Email & tools
       News by email
     Personal office
     Download news ticker
     Currency converter

    Research tools
       Analyst reports
     FT Research Centre
     Free annual reports
     Market research
     Growth companies
     D&B business reports

      Home World | Business | Markets news | Markets data & tools | Industries | Lex | Your money | Comment & analysis | Reports | Arts & Weekend | Sport | Jobs & education | In today's FT | Media inquiries Contact us | Help